The Sims Castaway for the PC and for the PS2 are 2 completely different games. Which one do you prefer or dislike?

I've completed the PC version several times, and I've been back and forth on the PS2 game since it first came out, and I finally finished it tonight! I found all the map pieces, the treasure and the hieroglyphics, and I got married!

Now I guess I'll start all over again with different people...why do they have to be so addictive!

I really can't make up my mind which one I prefer!