I've found most of the popular ones as far as I know. I have a few sets of wings, horns, and basic skintones. I've exhausted my knowledge of Google-fu (and MTS WCIF searches ) and most of the content I've found is for Sims 3, broken old links, or fantasy-esque CC like Halloween makeup. I want the real deal! Mainly looking for large changes like deer legs, hooves, wings, horns, traits, mods, halos, detailed skintones, animal ears & tails, etc. Anything that would totally transform a sim.

For anyone reading this that's in the same position, or to save time of anyone who'd like to help:

I already have

S-Club's Fairy Wings
S-Club's Devil Wings
S-Club's Angel Wings
everythingnotsim's Ram Horns
NotEgain's Fairy Tale Horn Accessory
Mikalinamikalina's Deer horns
Kalewa's Little & Large horns
Flapjack's Horns
Toskami's Ram Horns
NotEgain's various elf ears & dark elf skin tones
Lots more, I can try to figure out what exactly I have if anyone else is WCIF-ing like I am.

There's a few more items than you've mentioned over at http://sssvitlans.tumblr.com/themed .....http://sssvitlans.tumblr.com/tagged/s4fantasy.

I missed this! Thanks so much.